Five Biggest 401K Rollover Mistakes

December 28th, 2007  |  Published in 401K  |  4 Comments

401K rollovers are always tricky because they come at a time when there’s a lot of change in your life. Hopefully, it’s the result of a voluntary job change – you resigned amicably, you switched jobs, etc. Sometimes, it’s the result of an involuntary job change and those big changes are difficult; there’s no sense lumping on a few more financial mistakes with it right? The number one thing to understand with a 401k rollover is that you can wait. You don’t have to decide right now whether or not you’ll be rolling over your 401k into an independent Rollover IRA. If you have a lot on your plate right now, it pays to wait a little while before making the change.

If you are ready to do the rollover and you’ve analyzed the benefits and drawbacks, three of the five biggest rollover mistakes are:

  • Cashing out: Cashing out is the worst possible thing you could do because not only do you pay taxes on the withdrawal but there’s a penalty on top of it. Ignoring the fact that you’re pilfering your future, doing so reduces your money so tremendously that it’s almost never worth it to cash out (that’s the point!).
  • Not rolling over: This is a bit of a judgment call because your employer’s plan may not be all that bad, the risk is that you completely forget about it and decisions are made without your knowledge. It’s easy to just let it go on autopilot, especially if you don’t work at the company anymore, so oftentimes it’s better to roll it over to a brokerage and buy their funds. “Out of sight, out of mind” in this case is a bad thing.
  • Not directly rolling over the funds. When you rollover, you can have the 401k plan provider write a check directly to your new brokerage, called a trustee-to-trustee rollover; or they can cut you a check and you can write a new one. The second way, the check, is dangerous because you have sixty days to deposit the funds or it’s considered a cashout. One trip through the postal service is certainly better than two trips, especially if the two trips has a time limit with a hugely negative downside.

The two others aren’t as big of a deal, certainly not as bad as the first three, and you can read about David Bach’s take on all of them in this Yahoo Finance article.

  

Responses

  1. Honest Dollar says:

    December 28th, 2007 at 6:55 pm (#)

    A minor mistake: Rolling over into your new employer’s 401(k). This isn’t a horrible mistake since (if you roll it over directly into the new custodian) you won’t be hit with a penalty or a tax. However, an IRA at a reputable brokerage will give you far more investment choices, which can help you find better funds with lower fees.

    Exception is if new employer is a firm (most often a financial institution) that requires you to disclose all investment accounts (even retirement accounts) in which you can make trades. My employer not only required this disclosure, but I also had to roll any investment accounts into its brokerage. Consequently, I couldn’t just drop my 401(k) into an IRA. Still, I’m pretty happy with the fund choices in my 401(k) so I’m not too bad off.

  2. » Roundup: Happy New Year Edition! on Blueprint for Financial Prosperity says:

    December 31st, 2007 at 12:37 pm (#)

    […] out the top 5 retirement mistakes at My Retirement Blog. 12/30/07, Read more in Personal Finance | 34 […]

  3. scott brooks says:

    January 21st, 2008 at 7:50 pm (#)

    Not exploring NUA and the age 55 rule are two big mistakes.
    Other mistakes include chasing investment returns.

    If I had a $1 for every Rollover IRA that was demolished by the Nasdaq bubble I would be a rich man.

  4. webmaster a401 says:

    February 6th, 2011 at 2:40 pm (#)

    Thanks.It sounds simple, but “rolling over” a 401k can still go wrong if a few rules aren’t followed. One main rule is the same property rule, which prevents people from trying to make other income non-taxable. Basically, the money that you move has to be the same money in the account. You cannot, for example, take the money in your 401k account, purchase some other assets with those funds, and then deposit the money that is left into the new account. That purchase money will result in the ten percent penalty for an early withdrawal from your 401k.